Hey thanks Fellas! I enjoy doing it, just frustrated over trying to get all my vid together.
I'd def say the Winchester is at the bottom. The wad is a chunk of cardboard and the "cup" looks more like a saucer. The pattern, and one day I'll have it posted for you to see, of the Federal at 50 yards was tighter than the Winchesters pattern at 25 yards. The Federal 50 yard pattern was very similar to Hornadys 25 yard pattern. I liked the Remingtoin 00, but with only 4 pellets, the range would have to be close, like 10 yards or less, which I think is fine for a "designated HD" load. If it had more pellets, I think the pattern would have been only slightly wider than the Hornady at the same range. Another note, even though the Winchester load was a "full power" shell, it was the only in which the shot cup didnt penetrate the target. #1 reason; the shot cup is almost non-existent allowing the shot to begin spreading out as soon as it leaves the muzzle. The shot cup isnt following up the shot at all, it is haphazardly being broadcast towards the target.
But by far, the clear winner of the day was the Federal. 50 yard patterns were consistenly tighter than others at 25 yards. #1 reason; (I have it on video somewhere) the shot cup and wad are one piece and the cup is actually cup like and the shot fits into it rather than resting on top of it. This results in the shot staying together much longer and well beyond the end of the muzzle. This is evidenced by the 5 yard test results. The shot cup/wad which is the FliteControl technology, passed through drywall and plywood together with the shot.
Though the result at 5 yards is the same with the Hornady, the Hornady pattern began falling apart at 25 yards. While still better than Winchester, there were enogh strays outside the pattern to make me less than impressed, especially compared side x side to Federals 4 1/4" x 3 1/4" pattern at the same range.
It all comes back to Federal. There are no comprimises being made by purchasing Federal Tactical or Federal Premium ammunition. And honestly, I shop around and can find the low recoil FliteControl loads for less than the WalMart price on Win Super X.
Note:
I get nothing from Federal by telling you how much I like their stuff. I tested this stuff completely independant of support from any vendor/supplier/maker just because I wanted to.
Brad.