True, but If the light is used only for target identification (not for navigation, etc) and you keep moving that should not be much of an issue. Once you fire that first shot you've pretty much given up your position, esp if the first shot is not fatal or you are dealing with multiple targets.
True, but that's a given no matter what kind (or no sights) you have. Element of surprise and stealth is history when that 175 db shockwave goes out. And if just one threat, the first shot should be the most important anyway. And whether more than one confirmed threat or not, you better be ready for what's coming next.
The only shotgun I own that has a red dot on it is my turkey gun. Having been a shotgunner since I was big enough to hold one I am conditioned to get my cheek down on the stock and look down the barrel. I'm not even concious of the bead most of the time.
Me either.
As I learned to handle shotguns, instinctive shooting kicked in and shooting stuff on the move became more and more natural to me. It's generally as easy for me to hit a moving target as it is a stationary one, unless it's traveling at mach II But where I lack at that, is when it is pitch dark, then it's a whole other ballgame.
But like anything else, the brain can be trained to deal with any situation. Most red dots are zero power optics to you can easily use with both both eyes open to engage the target and let the dot fall where it needs to be, unlike a scope that magnifies, you don't have to squint and search for your target with a narrowed field of view.
Ultimately it's one of those personal things that you will have to play with and come to your own conclusions on what works best for you.
Well said.
For me, having a little glowing red dot at night reduces guess work exactly where that barrel is pointing especially if I can pick out a silhouette of the target and use the dot only as a point of reference. But I agree, isn't for everyone, but is what works pretty good for me.