The new one has about 50% of the dings, etc. that the first one did. I'm not accustomed to new guns being shipping in this, but "what can you do"... I just got it back together after a good cleaning and the worst area is the toward the end of the barrel. Whoever assembled it put the barrel/magazine bracket about two inches from the muzzle and marred both the barrel and magazine tube pretty badly; leaving the outline of the bracket down to bare metal. I cleaned up and retouched the outline, but you know how that goes. I've also go a problem with the safety getting stuck and it's very stiff to disengage.
At this point I'm into the project to the tune of $1400 (Benelli M3 $1400), so I'm more than a little bummed. I haven't decided if I'll shoot it or just unload it it at a loss. I'm going to think about something else for a while. Anyhow, I appreciate everyone's help and support. Ron