This is a great thread and a really exciting idea to discuss!!!!!!!!!
As I see it, this is just a result of a too-cool mould and lead not heated up, classic signs like wrinkling and raisin appearance and shiny silver finish:
This is called "tear-away" and it comes from having the lead really hot, maybe too hot (evidenced by the frosty granular granite-like finish) and the mould being also too hot; then hitting the sprue plate before the hot-as-hell lead and mould have settled down to make a solid cast slug. It isn't just with 1-oz slugs.... the tear-away happens all the time to casters who get things too hot and try to cut the sprue off too early. It's so common that it still happens to me quite often!!!!!!
ALSO, the molten lead that you pour from a ladle or a pot has to overfill the mould and sprue plate. When it's done properly as soon as you pour you can watch the molten lead actually suck down thru the sprue plate into the mould cavity. If there isn;t enough molten lead source sitting on top, the cooling/shrinking/pulling inside will run out of molten lead to fill the top of the mould.
Ideally, whether it is a single cavity or a six-banger you want some sprue cut-offs every time. That means you allowed sufficient molten lead to be sucked down into the mould cavity as things gelled up inside.
These slugs will work just fine.
Are they perfect? Well, no. But they aren't all that far from being so. They are close in temp, time, pour etc. but they just aren't right on the mark. Maybe let the mould cool some every time between pours so it isn't too cool but isn't so hot that it's makng frosty bullets, make sure the pot is around the optimum temp, and let the poured lead cool in the aluminum mould for several more seconds so you can get a clean slice from the sprue plate swipe. And pour enough to leave a puddle on top with enough molten lead to suck into the mould cavity whatever it needs.
Of course, I could be completely full of lies and deceit............