Re: Mesa Tactical Shell Holder
Reciever pinch is more of an issue with semi guns than pumps. You would really have to crank down on a pump gun to get it to stop working.
The 870 has a steel reciever, not aluminum so it is more resilient to receiver pinch than the 500/590. In that regard, the 870 is less likely to have a problem. Not immune, but less likely. Same with the 1100/1187 and the 9200/930 series.
The Mesas have had problems with reciever pinch in spite of the Chicago screws, and also with improperly sized Chicago screws. There were many people with problems in the 930 platform due to the Mesa sidesaddles.
On ID guns like the Benellis/HKs, the use of any sidesaddle can cause problems not due to receiver pinch but rather from increased mass, which prevents the ID system from cycling correctly.
If you want to completely eliminate reciever pinch, use one of the adhesive mounts like 3 Gun Gear or buy some industrial Velcro and use either a Vang, Original SOE Gear, 3 Gun Gear, or Esstac shotshell card.
The Vang carrier also uses a Chicago-type screw to secure the hard plate to the receiver along with an elongated stainless ejector screw replacement, and then uses Velcro to secure the shell holder to the mounting plate. It is a nice design and will work with any of the above shell holders.