Re: I'll show you mine if you show me yours! 590 photo threa
The opinions here are mine.
I do not work for nor receive compensation from HFD2
I do not know "Frank" in anyway other than as a customer.
I am not a gunsmith, or a particularly clever Mr. Build-It kind of guy. I'm a professional, end user, of firearms.
I am not a photographer (obviously)
Your results may differ.
Ok folks here is the Pumkin Puncher (part 1) AAR I promised.
This item is from Home Front Defense Devices
http://www.hfd2.com/#!pumkinpuncher/c1x9v and as you probably have seen I found this item secondary to a photo/ post here on this thread.
This AAR is a "part 1" because as of this writing I have not fully field tortured the device but I felt at a minimum folks might want to know about the business dealings and the academic side of installing the device.
First of all (as previously alluded) Frank McNitt at HFD2 was a no F'ing around standup guy to deal with. VERY responsive communications and humble to a fault. He was quick with answers, discussed the reasons for and behind the device and the issues he encountered during the R&D phase leading to the item being distributed.
Shipping was immediate and the puncher was in my possession on the 3rd day after my order. The package included all the required items AND tools (hex type wrench) and a tube of VC-3 goo for the threads.
The instructions sheet included was straight forward and while this isn't rocket science it did point out a couple esoteric things to consider that folks might otherwise not have attended to. Things like placing the puncher so that the set screw holes are not under the barrel and the sequence of tightening so as to create an evenly distributed attachment.
The puncher is of a good material and is sufficiently thick walled. This item is NOT heavy by any means but is obviously not flimsy.
It fits snugly over the tube cap and that is a good thing since the concept here is that the puncher is fastened in place by 6 set screws and basically just bites onto the cap. Therefore you do not want a loose fit to start. Having a loose fit would mean the set screws would have to be tightened in a more exacting and equal way to avoid the puncher being off kilter and or easily loosened under duress.
Let me just say real quick that the VC-3 goop is some messy shite!!!! No foul on Frank or his product but it became obvious that I have no ability to be delicate when it comes to tiny set screws and a tube of sticky stuff. Easily cleaned up however and if that stuff holds the threads as well as it pasted unrelated items on the table together I may never get that thing off my rig.
Ok so fully installed I gotta say the following couple things.
A- If nothing else it looks straight up badass. The CDI (chicks dig it) factor is definitely in play.
B-It's on there solid. This is important because I was initially uncertain how solidly this thing would be since it's ultimately only a slip on device. But as stated, 6 set screws thoroughly ratcheted down with the VC-3 seems to make this solid.
So. I have attached photos. Something I want to point out here is that this is not a "Safe Queen." I will not go into what I do for a living but suffice it to say that this rig and I work together. I sling it in a couple different ways (as you can see by the 2 diff attachment points) based on mission dictates. This rig has numerous upgrades from the stock 590A1 all of which because this is not a weekend warrior, one way, flat range, gun. This is also why I have purchased the puncher. If it works it will be a useful tool professionally. If it doesn't it will come off post haste.
I point this out because as you can see, I have a GG&G sling plate under the tube cap. This actually creates a solid flat base for the puncher to sit against. This was not a plan. The sling plate was there prior because again I sling a couple different ways. It is however a happy coincidence and I think will enhance a solid seat for the puncher. NOT that it would "need" the base plate, I think the design would be fine without it.
In summary:
Thus far, from the consumer side, it has been outstanding and should be the standard by which all businesses should function. The product is solidly designed physically and in concept.
For the money ($40) even if it doesn't work out very well it's certainly not the most expensive gun item I have bought and found useless. Don't deny it. You know you have crap in your cellar you thought was good and it wasn't.
ITEMS IN THE PACKAGE FROM HFD2
Note the GG&G plate referenced above.
The GG&G plate again. This is a good thing I think.
Time for a a lil sip and a Macanudo........
Hope you enjoyed.
Ask your questions.
AAR Part 2 will be the fun stuff!!